May 30, 2007

White Comanche (1967)



Customer Reviews
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:

With Yeagley and Captain Kirk?!!!, May 30, 2007
By Comanche Elder
See all my reviews

(TOP 500 REVIEWER)
“White Comanche” ... Two brothers who are twins, half white and half Comanche (an evil twin, Notah, played by William Shatner, and I forgive him for this), cannot reconcile their Indian selves. I watched for laughs until David Yeagley (the supposedly good Comanche, named Johnny) appeared in regalia with pink feathers. I lost it then ... my stomach still hurts from laughing!

Apparently, the common view of Yeagley is that he is “touched.” They tolerate his presence because Yeagley is viewed as crazy. So, the Comanche view him as relatively harmless. The overall view though is that he is not welcome at tribal gatherings. But, since he is crazy, no one wants to really talk to him. Well, given that Yeagley grew up as a runt with a childhood disease and couldn't play rough and tumble sports, played the piano, was half-not white and grew up in a white neighborhood, I'm willing to bet he got picked on and bullied quite a bit and now that he's bordering on being an old man with his own playground he can act out those fantasies of tormenting and getting even with the types of people who he thinks picked on him when he was a young runt.

Yeagley’s Comanche mother did not raise little David within Indian culture, because she disagreed with Indian ways and customs. Therefore, David “was raised with the values of White Anglo-Saxon Protestants” according to his blog. Yeagley was not taught Indian ways and cannot be considered Comanche. Much of what he thought was “Indian” came to him through his experience with whites. So, I suppose the film's one saving grace is the title, WHITE Comanche, truth be told.

3 comments:

The_Editrix said...

"To look and sound like an Indian, ... wears a headband and war paint."

***GIGGLE*** ***GIGGLE*** ***GIGGLE*** ***GIGGLE*** ***GIGGLE*** ***GIGGLE*** ***GIGGLE*** ***GIGGLE***

BRENT MICHAEL DAVIDS said...

Yes, leave it to Hollywood, Yeagley was not the first one to think up this idea, a white Comanche identity.

The_Editrix said...

I have no take on the question whether he is Indian by blood or not. It's just a fact that we are all living by clichés and see what is suggested to us. I guess with some grease applied to shorter hair he'd look as well Italian (or what the clichés about Italians tell us) or add a sombrero and hey presto -- we have a Mexican.

The fatuous moustache/forelock combination is a prime example for a cliché that works. No actor has ever needed more to emulate Hitler.

That said, as far as I am concerned, everybody could bleach his hair and wear Lederhosen to appear more "White" or "German" or whatever and I wouldn't care. To each his own aberration. Just in *his* case I am gleefully, spitefully, ROFLMAOly relieved that THAT wouldn't work. And no, not even after the umpteenth admiring article on Hitler. The "runt with a childhood disease" may use his website to discharge his hatred for people, but ONE thing he will never be and no cliché will come to his rescue. And I sit back and smile.